post new topic

Message for Mr Falafel

Related Forum Topics:
need recipes
Just looking for a little help with rec...
recipes and shite
Marrow recipes?
Recipes Wanted
Sausage recipes


Message for Mr Falafel - 2006/06/07 16:11 You've sometimes stated that recipes you submit are taken from various published cookbooks. I would like to ask you, therefore, if you could show some respect towards the authors/creators of these recipes by including their source, ie, author's name, book name, etc.



  Popular posts by heijs
Nutritional yeast and brewer yea...
Deep-Fried Bean Curd
Expired tofu
  | | | post reply
re:Message for Mr Falafel - 2006/06/07 23:37 It's not a non-issue for me. While I don't have a specific recipe that I'd like the source for, I really do think that it's respectful to those who created the recipes to be referenced in some way.

My family has produced several cookbooks and I know that it really pisses me off when I see those recipes pirated on the 'net with absolutely no credit give to the people who created them. They may have a few things changed, but they are close enough to be recognizable. I'm all for information sharing, but I don't see a contradiction between sharing information and crediting its source.

I think it's great that you, Mr Falafel, share so many recipes on this group. But I do think that you should take responsibility for the fact that you're not crediting them, and that in doing so, you're not giving recognition to the people who've developed the recipes (rather than writing it off as a 'non'issue'). Perhaps you could try to incorporate sources into any new recipes you add to your database?

Just my 2 cents,



  Popular posts by eddiewhittaker
Another bean curd recipe
Sunflower Seeds Vegan?
"ethical" bananas (was...
  | | | post reply
re:Message for Mr Falafel - 2006/06/08 04:10 Perhaps you could try to incorporate sources into

Responding to my own post....how low can I go?

Anyway, I was just looking at some of the most recent recipe posts and I noticed that some of them have already been credited. Just wanted to say thanks for that. I appreciate it. =)



  Popular posts by eddiewhittaker
Another bean curd recipe
Sunflower Seeds Vegan?
"ethical" bananas (was...
  | | | post reply
re:Message for Mr Falafel - 2006/06/08 08:28 While frolicking around in alt.food.vegan, Steve of
http://groups.google.com said:
I don't know why he does it, but am thankful that he does. Don't try to kidnap him from us, to r.f.v ;0)

Hm, maybe I should pop by in r.f.v and see what it looks like.



  Popular posts by tila
Recipe: Marinated Tempeh
Onion question
Peanut question
  | | | post reply
re:Message for Mr Falafel - 2006/06/08 10:19 He is just spreading the vegan wealth-- just get out your pans and cook and use you mouth for eating..



  Popular posts by skybomber
Heart attack suspected in McDonald'...
casein-cancer (was Thanksgiving...
Chinnappam
  | | | post reply
re:Message for Mr Falafel - 2006/06/08 14:04 Do you expect *him* to respect copyrights? Hahaha...



  Popular posts by Dell
casein-cancer (was Thanksgiving di...
Hundreds of horses left by uncaring...
  | | | post reply
re:Message for Mr Falafel - 2006/06/08 19:09 I don't think repeated copyright violations is a positive thing.



  Popular posts by Dell
casein-cancer (was Thanksgiving di...
Hundreds of horses left by uncaring...
  | | | post reply
re:Message for Mr Falafel - 2006/06/08 21:54 While frolicking around in alt.food.vegan, Steve of MYOB said:
I found out, and wondered why you had called it unmoderated. I've now changed to rec.food.veg.cooking, which looks a lot better. Thanks :0)



  Popular posts by tila
Recipe: Marinated Tempeh
Onion question
Peanut question
  | | | post reply
re:Message for Mr Falafel - 2006/06/09 01:17 I try to when I can. The problem is a while back I did a whole bunch of data entry of recipes without marking which recipe came from which book so now sometimes have a difficult time tracking down which recipe came from which source. Also, many recipes I publish come from magazines or my collection of bizarre out of print cookbooks found at charity shops or used book stores. Some of those do not list the recipe creators names. For instance, the Marmite recipes I just posted came from a Marmite recipe book published by the company...

Also, most of the recipes I post I'll simplify or 'internationalise' or offer ingredient alternatives or change around from my experience etc. At what point does a recipe stay with the author or become something new? I guess I could put 'inspired by' or similar credit in this case.

I also post recipes from non-vegetarian cookbooks. I would hate for someone to see a cookbook reference posted and have that person purchase the cookbook only to discover that there is only one or two vegan recipes in it. If a person asks me for a recipe reference, I can give out that type of information about the book.

If there is a specific recipe you are curious about then let me know and I'll try and track down it's source. Posting the recipes is supposed to inspire conversation and asking for a recipe source is a good way to establish two-way converstaion about a recipe, is it not?



  Popular posts by DePairet
Chapati
Wildlife Management: Do We Deserve ...
Marinated Mushroom Salad
  | | | post reply
re:Message for Mr Falafel - 2006/06/09 04:47 Doesn't look like anybody cares where the recipes come from as no one has asked for a specific recipe's source since this was posted.
Another non-issue, I guess.



  Popular posts by DePairet
Chapati
Wildlife Management: Do We Deserve ...
Marinated Mushroom Salad
  | | | post reply
re:Message for Mr Falafel - 2006/06/09 11:37 <snip>

Thanks for all you do Mr. Falafel.

Some of the recipies you have found for me have made a big difference in my daily life...like workable vegan kasha.

Just out of curiosity. rec.food.veg encourages only vegan recipeis to be posted and it is well moderated ( the content is JUST about recipes, food etc ). Given that why do you post here?



  Popular posts by spinner
The Top 10 Dirtiest Restaurants
Vegan Apple Pie Recipie ?
Soy: Does it feminize boys & me...
  | | | post reply